The box is the risk, not the box's contents
Holiday decorations spend roughly eleven months a year sitting undisturbed in a garage or attic, which is exactly the profile rodents look for: dark, quiet, and untouched for long stretches. A plain cardboard box shreds easily and readily becomes bedding, which is why extension guidance on rodent control names cardboard specifically as material to physically remove, not just seal (NPIC).
Swap the box, not the decorations. A hard-sided bin with a tight lid removes the nesting material in one move, and it's the same fix the flagship storage question on this hub already establishes for anything you want protected over a New Hampshire winter: metal and glass are the only container classes a gnawing rodent can't defeat, and heavy plastic buys time rather than certainty. For decorations specifically — mostly inert plastic, glass ornaments, string lights — a good hard-sided plastic tote with a tight lid is a reasonable trade-off; for anything genuinely valuable or food-adjacent, go harder.

